Reading the lower middle market through the noise
How to interpret mixed signals before timing a decision.
5 min readA brief reading of conditions across private markets at the halfway point of the year — less a forecast than an account of what has changed, and what has not.
Halfway through the year is a useful moment to take stock — not because markets observe the calendar, but because owners and boards tend to. Budgets are being revisited, second-half plans are taking shape and the question of whether this is a sensible time to raise capital, acquire or sell is being asked in a great many boardrooms.
What follows is not a forecast. We are wary of anyone who claims to know where private markets will be in six months, and more wary still of decisions built on such claims. It is, instead, a reading of conditions as they appear to us in June: what has shifted since the start of the year, what has stayed stubbornly the same, and what that might mean for owners of private businesses deciding what to do next.
The most important change in the first half has been a gradual easing in the availability of credit for good businesses. Lenders who spent much of the past period protecting existing portfolios have, in many cases, returned to looking for new ones. Conversations that would have stalled a year ago are now progressing. Private credit providers in particular remain active and eager to deploy capital.
That easing, however, has been selective. Lenders have grown more discerning about what they will finance and on what terms. Businesses with stable, recurring revenue, diversified customers and a credible management team are finding willing counterparties. Businesses with more cyclical earnings, recent volatility or heavy dependence on a single customer or founder are finding the conversation harder and the terms tighter. Covenant packages, equity cushions and the quality of financial reporting are all receiving closer attention than they did in easier years.
The cost of borrowing, meanwhile, remains meaningfully higher than the levels that shaped many owners’ expectations in the previous decade. This is no longer a shock; it has become the backdrop. But its effects continue to work through the system. Deals are being structured with less leverage, more equity and, increasingly, a greater role for seller financing and deferred consideration. For owners, the practical consequence is that the headline price of a transaction is now more closely tied to how it will be paid for.
For much of the recent past, the defining feature of private markets was a disagreement about value. Sellers anchored to the prices of an earlier cycle; buyers priced in a higher cost of capital and a more uncertain outlook. The result was a long period in which many processes were started, few were completed and a good number of businesses were quietly withdrawn from the market.
That gap has not closed, but it has narrowed. Some of the movement has come from sellers, many of whom have now absorbed the reality that conditions have changed and are no longer waiting for them to change back. Some has come from buyers, who have grown more comfortable underwriting in the current environment and, in many cases, are under growing pressure to put capital to work. Neither side has conceded much. But each has stopped expecting the other to concede everything.
Confidence among operators has been more mixed. Many of the owners we speak with describe businesses that are performing respectably, with demand holding up better than they feared, but with persistent pressure on costs and a lingering caution about committing to large investments. That combination — steady results, careful spending — is not a recipe for excitement. It is, however, a reasonably solid foundation for a transaction, because it gives buyers recent performance they can rely on.
The market has not returned to what it was. It has, more usefully, stopped waiting for that to happen.
The clearest signal of the first half has been a steady, unheralded increase in buyer activity. It has not been dramatic and it has not made headlines. But it has been noticeable in the number of inbound approaches owners are receiving, the seriousness of early conversations and the willingness of buyers to commit time and money to diligence.
Several forces appear to be at work. Financial sponsors are holding portfolio companies that need to be sold and capital that needs to be invested, and both pressures grow with time. Many have turned to add-on acquisitions as a way to build value in existing platforms without paying platform prices, which has made smaller, well-run businesses in fragmented sectors particularly attractive. Strategic buyers, for their part, appear more willing to pursue acquisitions that fill clear gaps in capability or geography, especially where the alternative is building slowly from scratch.
The character of this demand matters as much as its quantity. Buyers are returning, but they are returning with discipline. Diligence remains thorough and often lengthy. Quality of earnings work is examined closely. Claims about growth are tested against evidence. Buyers are also showing a marked preference for businesses that can demonstrate resilience — recurring revenue, customer longevity, a leadership team that does not depend on one person. In short, the buyers who are back are the selective ones, and they are paying properly for quality while remaining cautious about everything else.
Conditions like these reward preparation more than timing. An owner who is ready — with clean financials, a clear account of the business and a capable team — is likely to find interested and serious counterparties. An owner who is not ready may find that the improving market does little for them, because the scrutiny buyers now apply exposes the gaps quickly.
For boards and owners thinking about the months ahead, a few considerations seem worth discussing with their advisors:
None of these conditions is permanent, and some may look different by the end of the year. Interest rate expectations, broader economic data and events entirely outside anyone’s control will continue to shape the backdrop. But the underlying pattern — capital available for quality, scrutiny for everything, and buyers who are patient but present — seems likely to persist for some time. It is not an environment that rewards haste. It does reward those who use the quieter months to get ready.
Thinking about what the second half could mean for your business?
Start a conversationHow to interpret mixed signals before timing a decision.
5 min readNotes on where scrutiny now concentrates — and how sellers can prepare.
5 min readA framework for owners weighing reinvestment, acquisitions and distributions in a higher-rate environment.
5 min read