Five questions to ask before you commission a valuation

Purpose, standard of value and timing shape the answer more than most owners expect. Settling them first is the difference between a useful number and an expensive one.

Owners often approach a valuation as they might a property appraisal: a professional examines the asset and reports what it is worth. The reality is less tidy. A business does not have a single value waiting to be discovered. It has a range of defensible values, and which one a valuation arrives at depends heavily on choices made before the work begins — often by people who did not realise they were making them.

The consequence is familiar. An owner commissions a valuation for one purpose, then relies on it for another. A figure prepared for estate planning is brought into a sale negotiation. A number produced for a shareholder buyout becomes an anchor in a family conversation it was never designed to settle. The analysis may have been sound; it was simply answering a different question.

Five questions, asked at the outset, prevent most of this.

1. What is the valuation for?

Purpose comes first because it governs nearly everything else. A valuation to support a sale, to set the price of a partner’s exit, to satisfy a tax or reporting requirement, to inform a lender, to resolve a dispute, or simply to guide strategic planning will each be built differently. They draw on different assumptions, carry different levels of formality and face different audiences.

Be specific. “We want to know what the business is worth” is a reasonable instinct, but it is not yet a brief. “We want to understand the range a strategic buyer might pay in the next two years, and what drives the difference between the bottom and top of that range” is one. The clearer the purpose, the more useful the result — and the less likely it is to be misused later.

Where the purpose is formal — a tax filing, a court proceeding, a regulatory matter — the requirements are often prescribed, and the choice of valuer and approach should be made with legal and tax advisors involved from the start.

2. Which standard of value applies?

This is the question owners most often skip, and the one that most often explains a surprising answer. “Value” has several technical meanings. Fair market value typically assumes a hypothetical willing buyer and seller, neither under compulsion and both reasonably informed. Investment value reflects what the business is worth to a particular buyer, including the synergies that buyer alone might realise. Fair value has specific definitions in financial reporting and in certain legal contexts that differ again.

These are not shades of the same number. A business can be worth noticeably more to a strategic acquirer who can remove duplicate costs than it is under a fair market value standard that assumes no such buyer. Neither figure is wrong. They answer different questions, and the standard is frequently dictated by the purpose — sometimes by statute, a shareholder agreement or a court.

A valuation is not a fact about a business. It is an answer to a question — and the question is set before the work begins.

3. What exactly is being valued?

The subject of a valuation is rarely as obvious as it seems. Is it the whole enterprise, or a particular shareholding? A controlling interest, or a minority stake without the power to set dividends, appoint directors or force a sale? Shares that can be freely sold, or shares subject to transfer restrictions?

Each of these distinctions can move the result materially. Minority interests and illiquid holdings are commonly valued with adjustments for lack of control and lack of marketability, and the size of those adjustments is a matter of professional judgement that deserves examination. Owners are sometimes surprised to learn that the value of their stake is not simply their percentage of the whole.

The same care applies to what sits inside the perimeter. Is the property the business operates from included, or owned separately? Are there non-operating assets — surplus cash, investments, a holiday home on the balance sheet — that should be treated apart? Are there related-party arrangements, such as above- or below-market rent or owner compensation, that need normalising before earnings mean anything to an outsider? Agreeing these points early avoids an argument later about whether the number is “right”.

4. As of when?

Every valuation has a valuation date, and the choice matters more than the paperwork suggests. A business valued at the end of an unusually strong year looks different from the same business valued after a difficult quarter. Market conditions, interest rates and buyer appetite at the valuation date all feed into the result, and none of them stand still.

For formal purposes the date is often fixed by events — a death, a transaction, a dispute, a reporting period. For planning purposes there is more latitude, and that latitude is worth using thoughtfully. A valuation commissioned in the middle of a major operational change, before its effects are visible in the numbers, may understate what the business is becoming. One commissioned too far ahead of a decision may be stale by the time it is needed.

It is also worth asking how long the conclusion is expected to remain useful. A valuation is a snapshot. Owners who intend to rely on one over time should plan for when, and on what basis, it will be refreshed.

5. Who will rely on it — and what will they need to see?

The final question concerns the audience. A valuation prepared for the owner’s own planning can be relatively informal and candid about uncertainty. One that will be read by co-owners, family members, lenders, a tax authority or a court needs to withstand scrutiny from people with different interests and, sometimes, opposing advisors.

The answer shapes several practical choices:

  • Independence. If others will rely on the conclusion, the valuer’s independence from the outcome becomes central to its credibility.
  • Depth of work. A calculation, a limited-scope estimate and a full opinion of value differ in rigour, cost and how much weight they can bear.
  • Transparency of method. Readers who did not commission the work need to follow the reasoning — the approaches used, the key assumptions, and how sensitive the conclusion is to changing them.
  • Quality of inputs. A valuation can be no more reliable than the financial information beneath it. Unreviewed accounts, inconsistent management reporting or unexplained adjustments weaken any conclusion, however careful the analysis.

That last point is worth dwelling on. Many owners discover, in the course of a valuation, that the most useful output is not the number but the list of things that made the number harder to support: earnings that depend on one customer, forecasts no one has tested, adjustments that cannot be evidenced. Those findings are an agenda for the years ahead.

None of these five questions is complicated. But answering them deliberately, before engaging anyone, turns a valuation from a figure to be admired or resented into a tool that informs a decision. The number matters. The question it answers matters more.

Thinking about a valuation, and what it should answer?

Start a conversation
More perspectives View all